VietNamNet Bridge - There are three essential factors that
affect the value of agricultural land: time for land allocation, restrictions
on land conversion and the underdeveloped land market.
Major assets
As being mentioned before, the
Constitution and the Land Law stipulates that land is owned by the people.
Personal ownership of land has no value. The value of land is only for the
access to the use of land, which is worth billions of US dollars.
It is estimated that the value of
land in Vietnam is about $200 billion. The estimation method takes into account
the following things: in 2009 the value of the stock market was $35 billion;
fixed assets and equipment of $240 billion; supply of money $115 billion (of
which $20 billion was foreign exchange reserves); gold reserves of $24 billion.
The main economic activities
generated $94 billion and $127 billion was the total import-export turnover. By
any measure, the cumulative value of land in Vietnam is huge.
For most Vietnamese farmers, land
is a major asset and a fundamental part of their wealth. The current Land Law
allows farmers the right to use, transfer, lease, inherit, mortgage/present
land and use land as capital contribution.
Farmers cannot use agricultural
land for non-agricultural purposes. According to the law, farmers need the local
government’s permission to use rice land to other agricultural purposes. The
time of land use is limited. For individuals and households who cultivate
annual crops and aquaculture, they are allowed to use land for 20 years and 50
years for perennial crops and forest land.
The law also sets the land limit
for each household in each soil type. For annual crops, the land limit in the
North and Central Region is two hectares and three hectares in the South. For
perennial crops, the land limit is 10 hectares in the plains and 30 hectares in
the midlands and mountainous.
In fact, the farmer's land use
rights are restricted, narrowed and closely supervised.
The value of agricultural land
depends on the demand for land use in the present and in the future. This
demand will depend on the efficiency of agricultural activities, and the number
and quality of services to support agricultural production.
Land prices are also affected by
the institutions that regulate the forms of land use and limit the ability to
convert land use purposes.
The main agricultural activities
include production of food (rice, fruits, vegetables, maize and cassava),
livestock, aquaculture and industrial crops (rubber, coffee, pepper). Farmers
can increase the value of their land through investment in raising production
capacity of land, such as improving irrigation systems, the fertility of land,
practicing good husbandry, fertilization, controlling weed and invasive
species, to protect crops and livestock from disease and insects. Farmers can
enhance or maintain the value of land by working with neighbors to improve the
anti-flood infrastructure, plant trees or build protection perimeter, maintain
roads for production.
The above discussion shows that
the non-agricultural activities affect the productivity of agricultural land
and thus affect the value of the land. Agricultural costs are affected by the
quality of infrastructure services (transport, storage, irrigation and
communications), the level of competition in the market for the input, the
output of agricultural production, and the availability of appropriate market
information. Labor productivity of farmers, their families and agricultural
support services depend on the quality of public services in health, education
and security (to protect the property of people).
Finally, the prices of output are
directly affected by income growth of urban areas and the expansion of the
export markets for agricultural products.
Land used for non-agricultural
purposes, namely for urbanization and industrialization, also affects the price
of agricultural land.
Along with the process of
modernization and economic restructuring, land use for non-agricultural
purposes will increase the opportunity cost of individuals and society as a
whole if land continues to be kept for agricultural production. Income and
population growth in urban areas promotes the demand for real estate in the
area adjacent to the main urban areas and the areas on the corridors connecting
these urban areas. This demand makes about 600,000 hectares of agricultural
land be converted into non-agricultural land in recent decades.
A fundamental part of the value
of the converted land is "the rental conversion." This land rent
depends on the location of the land, the growth of the local economy, the
quality of the accompanying infrastructure, and the potential for industry,
commerce and other potential. This land rent is also affected by the
"overflow effect" from the market of the property that can replace.
The "overflow effect" has
directly connected the value of land with macro-economic management. In the
period of macroeconomic stability, as being proven by stable economic growth,
balanced budgets, low inflation, moderate money supply growth, balance of
payments stability, reasonable exchange rate, and the ability to repay foreign
debt on a sustainable basis, the holder of property (both domestic and
overseas) have very little desire to adjust the portfolio. They are easily
satisfied with existing forms of accumulation, having regard to the liquidity
and risk by holding combination of different properties including the local
currency, banking credit, stocks, gold, real estate, foreign currencies and
other assets including land.
However, with budget deficit,
domestic credit supply being much higher than real economic growth, high
inflation, the exchange rate remaining high compared with real value, balance
of payments worsening, and public debt growing faster than GDP, the property
owners will be looking for safe solutions. Vietnamese people tend to switch to
investing in gold, foreign exchange, imports and real estate. Extending the
land market in the 1980s brought the ability to obtain land use rights in the
above portfolio.
Macroeconomic management in
Vietnam has caused the inflation trend that makes those who have assets adjust
the portfolio. And this trend has been persisted from the 1990s to the present.
More specifically, in the period 2005-2008 when the economy grew at 7.8 percent
per year, total credit increased by an average of 34 percent per year. This is
partly related to the "official" budget deficit and non-budgetary
expenditure and is equivalent to 5 percent of annual GDP.
Inflation increased from 8.3
percent in 2005 to 23.1 percent in 2008. At the same time, the current account
deficit in the balance of payments increased from 1 percent up to 10.3 percent
of GDP and the nominal exchange rate fluctuated from VND15,907/$1 in 2005 to
VND17,486 /$1 at the end of 2008. Inflation rate fell down because the world
economic crisis made the reduction of demand of the external market. Land and
real estate prices, thus, also reduced.
The factors such as the increase
of income, productivity and export expansion, urbanization and industrialization
in general make the increase of land value. However, farmers are the group that
benefits the least. Limitations on agricultural land reduces the productivity
and value of land.
Three key limitations
There are three essential factors
that affect the value of agricultural land: time of land allocation,
restrictions on land conversion and the underdeveloped land market.
For cropland, the land use right
certificate is valid for 20 years. Under the 2003 Land Law, the deadline is
2013. Short time of land allocation make people are not interested in long-term
investment in land to increase the productivity of land. Vietnam will learn a
lot if it is interest in international studies, which show that short-term
allocation of land will inhibit investment and reduced farm incomes.
Deeper consequences of the
short-term allocation of land is the obstruction of the inheritance, mortgage
of land use rights. Many farmers can die within 20 years, and if they know that
their children are entitled to inherit their land in the remaining term will
reduce the value of land. The Land Law of 1993 says that the Government may
extend the time of land allocation after 2013. However, this also implies that
farmers will only be voluntary land tenant.
The restriction of the ability to
convert paddy land for other agricultural purposes also reduces the value of
land. Numerous studies in Vietnam indicate that income from rice is usually 3-5
times lower than the income from other seasonal products such as vegetables, fruit
and seafood. The Government has paid attention to this matter and the Prime
Minister has asked two state-owned food corporations to calculate the floor
price to make profit for rice farmers of at least 30 percent.
This requirement makes clear the
inequity of land use restrictions. Having to plant rice means farmers have to
support the Government to achieve rice self-sufficiency in national food
security policy. Farmers do not get the tangible reward for their service for
the common benefits. 30 percent of the profit is calculated based on the narrow
definition of the actual production cost so in fact, people are not being paid
properly for their efforts.
With income from rice production
of only about $28/person/month, half of the farmers who plant 4 million
hectares of rice in Vietnam are adjacent to the poverty threshold of the
country.
Land use restrictions also reduce
the attractiveness of land in the market. Low-income prevents rice farmers from
accumulating land for production. More importantly, while the land is locked
with rice planting, people are not interested in buying more land. They realize
that if they expand land and when their land is revoked, compensation will not
reflect the real value that they have to pay when buying.
The above injustice in the above
restrictions will be further demonstrated when a number of farmers
participating in the game with the current system. Although there are many
risks, some farmers have accumulated more land by dividing their land into many
"red books" in the name of their relatives and friends.
Ho Dang Hoa, Le Thi Quynh Tram,
Pham Duy Nghia and Malcolm F. McPherson
Business & Investment Opportunities
YourVietnamExpert is a division of Saigon Business Corporation Pte Ltd, Incorporated in Singapore since 1994. As Your Business Companion, we propose a range of services in Strategy, Investment and Management, focusing Healthcare and Life Science with expertise in ASEAN. Since we are currently changing the platform of www.yourvietnamexpert.com, you may contact us at: sbc.pte@gmail.com, provisionally. Many thanks.
No comments:
Post a Comment