It
may not be as easy as it looks
Resource-rich Burma is looming as one of the
world’s final investment frontiers for Western companies battling a prolonged
downturn in the EU and feeble growth in the US.
Subject to Western sanctions for decades but
possessing a population of nearly 60 million, as well as abundant reserves of
natural gas and other natural resources, Burma, also represents one of Asia’s
last untapped paradises for potential investors. It can also represent one of
Asia's biggest traps.
Visit the sleepy Myanmar International
Terminal Thilawa (MITT) complex in Kyauktan township outside Yangon and you
might just find a cement bagging factory bearing the logo of French company
LaFarge. Opened in 1997 by then-Prime Minister Khin Nyunt -- who was released
from house arrest only last week after falling out with other members of the
junta -- the plant never filled a single bag of cement. Today the gate is
locked and overgrown with weeds and the guard’s hut has been vacant for a long
time.
Malaysian billionaire Robert Kwok likewise
invested heavily in the 1990s through his Shangri-La group. The company’s
Traders Hotel has benefited from the recent influx of business and leisure
travellers but other ventures, such as the seemingly abandoned condominium
towers at the edge of Kandawgyi Lake and his port at MITT, have not fared so
well.
More recently, Burma’s newly installed,
notionally democratic government led by President Thein Sein has exhibited a
populist streak absent under the former military leaders, and axing unpopular
projects regardless of their size or cost.
In September last year Thein Sein suspended
the widely unpopular Myitsone dam project in Kachin State, which had an
estimated price tag above US$20 billion and was being developed by China Yunnan
Power Investment to ship 80 percent of the power to China.
Then, just a fortnight ago the government
announced that Italian-Thai Development, which is building a $58 billion
deep-sea port, special economic zone and 4000-megawatt powerplant in Myanmar’s
southeastern town of Dawei in Tanintharyi Region, via the media, that it could
no longer use coal to fuel the power plant.
U Khin Maung Soe, Minister of Electric Power
2, told journalists on Jan. 9 at the Yangon Electricity Supply Board
headquarters in Ahlone township that the ministries of energy, industry and
electric power 1 and 2 had decided to stop the plant going ahead.
He cited “fear of the adverse effects on the
environment” as the reason for the cancellation.
Ital-Thai is cooperating with Ratchaburi
Electricity Generating Holdings to develop the plant and Ratchaburi president
Noppol Milinthanggoon told Bangkok Post on Jan. 11 that his company had not
received an official notice from the government.
"It needs to be verified thoroughly
before making any comment," he said, adding that it would be better to let
Italian-Thai Development speak because that company holds 25 percent of the
proposed power project.
But Somchet Thinaphong, the managing director
of Dawei Development Co, the company established by Ital-Thai to oversee the
Dawei project, said: “If they don't want coal-fired power plants, we have to
look for other fuel sources. It could be natural gas, and we'd need to discuss
how to supply that."
The highly publicized case of Australian
newspaper publisher Ross Dunkley, spectacularly captured in the documentary
movie “Dancing With Dictators,” ought to make any foreign investor pause and
reconsider.
Dunkley was arrested and jailed on charges
stemming from an alleged incident with a prostitute, who claimed the colourful
Australian had beaten her, fed her illicit drugs and detained her against her
will.
Despite her later efforts to have the charges
withdrawn, Dunkley spent 47 days in jail.
Just months before the incident Dunkley
received a letter from Minister for Information Kyaw Hsan demanding that he
hand over control of the Myanmar Times newspaper to his Burmese partner, Dr Tin
Tun Oo, who holds 51 percent of Myanmar Consolidated Media, publisher of The
Myanmar Times.
Despite those cases, as Asia Sentinel detailed
in a Jan. 10 article, over recent weeks a stampede of prospective investors has
expressed interest in the country, including a Japanese delegation, the
Templeton Emerging Market Group, Colliers International Thailand and others.
Myanmar "represents not only an export
manufacturing base but a significant future domestic market as well," said
associate director Antony Picon of Colliers. "This is a key component for
even export-led manufacturers. It also ticks all the right boxes in tourism
such as beaches, culture, temples and an aesthetic commercial centre in Yangon.
“Companies from all fields such as
hospitality, manufacturing, medical services, banks and fund management are all
interested. Myanmar will not be a niche market but a fully-fledged economy,” he
added.
Dr Nicholas Farrelly, an Australian National
University academic and moderator of the New Mandala website, said the damage
to company image from investing in Burma was fading but hasn't disappeared.
“Boycott campaigns get less traction than ever
before but there is still a sense in Australia, as elsewhere, that regressive
moves by the government could still occur. That's the risk for Australian
businesses. They don't want to get caught if the wind changes direction,” he
said.
“Western democracies and their business elites
want to see Myanmar move so far ahead that it can never go back,” he added.
But Myanmar has a rich history of backtracking
on reforms and potential investors would do well to consider both recent events
and those that occurred as the Asian Financial Crisis swept the region in 1997.
Since it opened up to foreign investment in
1988 following Ne Win’s disastrous socialist economic policy, known as the
Burmese Way to Socialism, Burma has been a graveyard for many an unwary foreign
investor.
That said, removal of sanctions obviously
opens the field for investment dramatically, and importantly it changes their
nature. Previously, it was necessary to do business with members of the junta
on a large-ticket basis. As in Indonesia and China, to name two, it is
necessary to take a local partner, preferably one with guanxi. It is difficult
to say who the new parties will be, although many of the groups that have been
at the trough through the decades are a potential serious liability to foreign
partners, because any investigation of previous recent deals won't be pretty.
Investors should be looking for new
"cleaner" players. Steven Law, the old buddy of Asia World fame and
others are seen by some influential new groups and by new blood in the cabinet
as having done quite well enough in the past and it's time to lessen government
reliance on them.
It will remain very difficult to do business,
however. The entire economy and governance need to be rebooted, which will take
time although removal of the sanctions broadens everyone's opportunity and is a
critical first step in the process. It must be noted that, importantly press
freedom is evolving quite rapidly as is internet access and usage, which can be
expected to raise the level of scrutiny on every major project and deal, which
should represent a new playing field.
Potential investors are clearly aware of the
risks of doing business. Douglas Clayton, chief executive of Leopard Capital, a
private equity investor in frontier markets, told the BBC on January 5 that the
greatest fear for investors is that the recent political reforms could be
reversed.
“Perhaps the most feared risk is a rollback of
the entire liberalisation agenda, should impatient democracy advocates or
separatist insurgents provoke globally-unacceptable military crackdowns,"
Clayton said. “It is easy to imagine that hardliners lurk within Burma's
military who would like to derail the ambitious democratization and economic
liberalisation process.”
And those who expect US sanctions to be
removed in the short term are likely to be disappointed.
James M Roberts
Asia Sentinel
James M Roberts, lead expert in economic
freedom and growth at the Heritage Foundation, a conservative US think tank,
said: “Lifting the sanctions is a long, very involved political process here,
closely tied to meaningful systemic political reform in Burma.”
Business & Investment Opportunities
YourVietnamExpert is a division of Saigon Business Corporation Pte Ltd, Incorporated in Singapore since 1994. As Your Business Companion, we propose a range of services in Consulting, Investment and Management, focusing three main economic sectors: International PR; Healthcare & Wellness;and Tourism & Hospitality. We also propose Higher Education, as a bridge between educational structures and industries, by supporting international programs. Sign up with twitter to get news updates with @SaigonBusinessC. Thanks.
No comments:
Post a Comment