Religion as geopolitics
The Buddhist holy sites of Bodh Gaya in India
and Lumbini in Nepal -- two of the religion’s most sacred pilgrimage locales,
are becoming the dual epicenters of a Great Game between India and China.
Bodh Gaya is considered the undisputed
heartland of the Buddhist world. However, Bodh Gaya’s eminence is being
challenged by the Hong Kong-based Asia Pacific Exchange and Co-operation
Foundation, which is backing Lumbini as Prince Siddhartha Gautama's birthplace.
The foundation’s executive vice chairman, the Beijing-born Xiao Wunan, has
described developing Lumbini into a Mecca as part of scheduled Chinese US$3
billion investment in Nepal.
For hundreds of years the faithful have
flocked to Bodh Gaya, a small town some 100 kilometers south of Patna, the
capital of the Northeastern Indian state of Bihar, bordering the Himalayas.
Known in the Buddha’s time as Uruvela, it is the place where all Buddhas have
become enlightened. It is here where Prince Gautama Siddhartha was said to have
sat down under a pipal tree and entered into deep meditation after six years of
wandering, becoming The Buddha. The pipal tree, a species of fig, became known
as the Bodhi or Bo – enlightenment -- tree. The tree now at the site is said to
have been descended from the original Bodhi tree. For Buddhists, a red
sandstone slab marking the spot of the Buddha’s first meditation is said to be
the center of the universe.
Growing Chinese influence is something that
New Delhi and Moscow both admire and fear. Chinese displeasure was enough to
force the cancellation of Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s planned speech
at the Global Buddhist Congregation conference in Delhi in November 2011
conference (along with all major Indian MPs), although Delhi drew the line at
cancelling the event altogether, which was what Beijing really wanted.
Lumbini, 171 km. southeast of Kathmandu, is a
key component in the Chinese objective to dislodge Nepal from India’s orbit as
a satellite state. The Chinese investment is designed to transform the
currently sleepy town into a first-class tourist destination including a new
airport and highway, hotels, a convention center, a Buddhist university and
place of pilgrimage for Buddhists from around the world.
According to the Xinhua News Agency, in July,
the United Nations Industrial Development Organization and the Asia Pacific
Exchange and Cooperation Foundation signed a memorandum of understanding in
Beijing in Beijing to begin the development of Lumbini.
The Nepalese government was irritated over not
being consulted, eventually prompting Beijing to deny reports in the Nepali
media of a secret pact with elements of the country’s Maoists and instead
saying they had signed the MOU with Tourism Minister Khagda Bahadur, also a
Maoist leader. Pushpa Kamal, who goes by the nom de guerre Prachanda, the head
of the Maoist party, is a co-chairman of the APEC Foundation along with Steven
Clark Rockefeller Jr, a fifth-generation member of the Rockefeller family; Jack
Rosen, chairman of the American Jewish Congress, and Leon Charney, a real
estate tycoon and former US presidential adviser
Executive vice chairman Xiao has said publicly
that he hopes Lumbini will bring together all Buddhist schools -- Mahayana as
practiced in China, Japan, and South Korea, Hinayana as practiced in Southeast
Asia; and Tibetan Buddhism.
Apparently, however, according to media
reports, the one Buddhist that Beijing intends to have nothing to do with the
Lumbini project may well be the most influential one in the world today – the
exiled Tibetan leader the Dalai Lama, who heads the Gelug, or Yellow Hat branch
of Buddhism. It seems thaty no one connected with the Lumbini project has
contacted the Buddhist leader’s Dharmasala, India office to invite him to
participate. China regards him as an outlaw and a renegade out to foment
rebellion in Tibet.
After decades of professing atheism as the
state’s official policy by the Communist Party, whose official stance is that
religion is the opiate of the masses, President Hu Jintao declared a
“harmonious society” policy in 2006. Since that time, Chinese influence in
religion has been growing, with the proviso that Beijing effectively gets to
pick the leaders, as it does with the Catholic Church branch in China. Thus
Beijing’s influence in Buddhist affairs in particular has been growing. The
party selected its own Panchen Lama, the religion’s second highest official,
after spiriting away the Tibetan religion’s own reincarnated child, and vainly
attempting to educate the Karmapa Lama in socialist doctrine until he made his
dramatic escape from China and joined the Dalai Lama in India.
This is post-Cultural Revolution, face-saving
code for “ally yourself to Beijing, and you will enjoy freedom and benefits.”
It has paid off for most Buddhist institutions in China. The bid to co-opt the
Buddhist faith is considered a part of dominating the Himalayan region, which
Beijing considers essential if China is to continue reaping the benefits of its
influence over the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, a mutual security
organization founded in 2001 by China, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Russia,
Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. Although Russia is nominally an equal member, Moscow
worries that it is losing out to its onetime protégé’s economic allure and soft
power.
This is especially so with the establishment
of Confucius Institutes in many Central Asian nations save Tajikistan, and
training its young, bright and promising youth in Mandarin. In a throwback to
the Han and Tang dominance of the Silk Road and the imperialist Qing, China’s
hydroelectric and manufacturing clout in post-Soviet breakup countries are
prompting Russia to reengage with the Central Asian and Eastern European power
blocs.
China also enjoys with the Central Asian
countries the benefit of buffering the impoverished zone of Xinjiang, which is
likely to be politically volatile in future due to the Tibetan Buddhist and
Uighur Muslim mix (China’s elite counterinsurgency forces, the Snow Leopards,
are currently deployed in the region).
Buddhism also forms a second front of
religious diplomacy between China and a different power bloc, and that is the
Pacific-Atlantic superpower of the United States. Since the Chinese occupation
of Tibet, the Dalai Lama has been a promoter of “universal” values - a word
that translates in Beijingese as “Western” or “American.”
This has resulted in a worst-case scenario for
Chinese Buddhists as well as Chinese people who practice Tibetan Buddhism:
having to choose between condemning a perfectly legitimate Tibetan religious
leader or falling into the media trap of Tibet as an enlightened Shangri-la
with bouncing bodhisattva bunnies before the PLA occupation.
This choice grows more agonizing with each
Tibetan that sets herself or himself alight. After appointing its own Panchen
Lama, all reincarnations of Tibetan Buddhist leaders are now to be approved by
the state, raising concerns that this means the future Dalai Lama must be
chosen by Beijing. The story on the Tibetan side, of course, is much more
complex and private, and the Dalai Lama is far more long-term thinking than
Beijing wants him to be.
Seen in this light, China’s paranoia about
Tibet is no ill-thought out choice but a reluctant one, made by the party
despite knowing it makes them look immature and out of touch. It fits quite
well into the bigger picture that we shall see this century.
This curious chess game has led to am ironic
observation on my part at the Global Buddhist Congregation conference in Delhi
that the Chinese sought to stop, there were plenty of Taiwanese Buddhists there
as well as Malaysian, Singaporean, ones, etc., almost all of whom are Chinese
Buddhists, but almost not a single Buddhist from the mainland. I was one of the
few Buddhists from Hong Kong.
The institution of the temple and monastery -
the sangha - is above the ever-fluctuating fortunes of secular politics. 2600
years of watching over sentient beings is what it will forever do. In the
meantime, however, innocents are dying as sacrifices in the Great Games of
superpowers. Buddhists struggle as much as anyone else to find solutions, having
been swept up as diplomatic pawns that could checkmate the king, or at least
trap the queen.
Raymond Lam
Asia Sentinel
Business & Investment Opportunities
YourVietnamExpert is a division of Saigon Business Corporation Pte Ltd, Incorporated in Singapore since 1994. As Your Business Companion, we propose a range of services in Consulting, Investment and Management, focusing three main economic sectors: International PR; Healthcare & Wellness;and Tourism & Hospitality. We also propose Higher Education, as a bridge between educational structures and industries, by supporting international programs. Sign up with twitter to get news updates with @SaigonBusinessC. Thanks.
No comments:
Post a Comment