New report says nearly US$4 trillion disappeared – 10 percent of GDP
An astonishing US$3.97 trillion
in illicit funds left China between 2000 and 2011, according to a report
released Friday by the Washington, DC-based Global Financial Integrity, a
research and advocacy group.
As much as 10 percent of China’s
annual gross domestic product may be disappearing out of the country in illicit
funds flight, says the 15-page report, titled Illicit Financial Flows from
China and the Role of Trade Misinvoicing.
The capital flight is hidden in
opaque stratagems on the part of businessmen and corrupt officials to attempt
to make sure governments don’t catch them. Consequently the report relies on
what amount to the best guesses of government regulatory agencies, private
corporations, and others.
“Such survey results indicate
that globally, tax evasion by high-net-worth-individuals and corporations
comprise by far the largest component (around 65 percent) of cross-border
illicit flows from developing countries, followed by the proceeds of crime (30
percent) and corruption (5 percent),” the report notes.
Trade misinvoicing – described as
the illegal trade of legal goods – is held responsible for outflows amounting
to US$172 billion in 2000, rising to US$602.9 billion in 2011, an increase of
about 7.2 percent annually, according to the report, written by Dev Kar, a
former senior economist at the International Monetary Fund, and Sarah Freitas,
a Global Financial Integrity group economist.
“One of the adverse effects of
illicit flows from China has been a worsening of the country’s income
inequality as the rich get richer through tax evasion (which comprises by far
the major portion of such outflows) and through using the world’s shadow
financial system to shelter and multiply their illicit wealth,” the report
adds.
Nearly US$600 billion of the
illicit flows ended up as cash deposits or financial assets such as stocks,
bonds, mutual funds and derivatives in the British Virgin Islands, the Caymans
and other tax havens. An uncertain amount of that is then “roundtripped” back
in what the report describes as a “complex money-laundering scheme used in
order to take advantage of favorable regulations for FDI and to allow high net
worth individuals to secretly accumulate wealth in contravention of government
regulations and oversight.
Most of the money is routed
through Hong Kong, making the territory, with about 7 million people, the
world’s third-largest recipient of foreign direct investment, at more than
US$80 billion in 2011, a leap from US$52 billion in 2009. Such round-tripped
FDI is given preferential treatment vis-à-vis domestic capital such as tax
concessions, government guarantee of loans extended by foreign corporations to
domestic firms, land and other facilities at concessional rates, etc, the
report notes.
To give some idea of the
magnitude of these cash flows, the report notes, “For example, in 2010, if we
go clockwise starting from China, US$366.5 billion flowed out to Hong Kong
which invested US$356.7 billion in the BVI which in turn invested US$213.7
billion back into China, accounting for US$936.9 billion circulating as FDI
among the troika. In that same year, if we go counter-clockwise, BVI invested
US$324.3 billion in Hong Kong which invested US$710.9 billion in China. Even if
reported data does not show that the latter invested back in BVI, the amount in
circulation among the troika total slightly more than US$1 trillion.”
Hong Kong’s position as recipient
of direct foreign investment is the largest in Asia after China itself and far
ahead of its Asian rival, Singapore, at just over US$60 billion according to
the United Nations Commission on Trade and Development’s World Development
Report 2012. It is the region’s biggest source of capital outflows as the money
is reinvested back in to China after having been legitimized via its voyage
through the territory.
Some of that money does move out
of those BVI and Caymans accounts into businesses overseas, raising hope that
Asia might play a role in pulling the Eurozone out of its continuing economic
crisis. But probably the preponderance is rolled into the property markets of
Canada, the United States, Singapore and to some extent Europe. With the US
slowly emerging from its five-year-old real property meltdown, some realtors in
New York are studying Mandarin, according to a recent New York Times article,
to be more receptive to Chinese buyers.
The real property consultants
Colliers International estimate that Chinese mainlanders constitute 20 to 40
percent of foreign investors in London, Toronto, Vancouver and Singapore. One
enterprising developer in Spain built a new project with Chinese-style
buildings including a courtyard, pavilion, ponds and supposedly checked out by
a feng-shui expert to make sure the wind and water aspects were in line.
Mis-invoiced trade between
Chinese companies and the United States increased from US$48.8 billion in 2000
to US$59.0 billion in 2011, the report says. The commodity groupings most
susceptible to trade misinvoicing include UN Commodity Trade Statistics
Database group 84 – nuclear reactors, boilers, machinery, etc. – and group 85,
consisting of electrical and electronic equipment, with the sub-group for
electronic circuits showing the largest cumulative illicit outflows (US$84.1
billion). Trade misinvoicing related to the sub-group for mobile phones
increased at the fastest pace from 2007-2011.
Mainland China and Hong Kong are
the largest foreign direct investors in each other’s economy, with the BVI
serving as the second-biggest foreign direct investor in both mainland China
and Hong Kong. The BVI also serves as the largest recipient of FDI from Hong
Kong.
“Indeed, the report continues,
“it appears that while the BVI invested a massive US$213.7 billion in mainland
China in 2010, nearly all reciprocal investment in the BVI from the Chinese
mainland was routed through Hong Kong. The BVI has a population of about 28,000
and a GDP of only around US$1.1 billion, so it is hard to see how it can
undertake such massive FDI outflows unless funds were routed back in via Hong
Kong, and/or subsidized by illicit funds.”
On average, roughly 52.4 percent
of investments that flowed into tax havens were illicit financial flows or
illegal capital flight involving money that is illegally earned, transferred,
or utilized. While the funds could be earned through bribery, kickbacks, or
other illicit activities, they may well be earned through legitimate means. It
is the transfer in contravention of capital controls or the nonpayment of
applicable taxes that renders the funds illicit.
Outflows of illicit capital from
developing countries overall have been a growing problem over the past decade.
According to the latest annual report, developing countries lost between US$775
billion and US$903 billion in 2009, down from the previous report’s estimate of
US$1.26 to US$1.44 trillion in 2008. The main reason for the 2009 falloff was
due to the economic downturn, which reduced foreign direct investments, new
loans, and trading volumes.
Global Financial Integrity
studies show that cross-border transfers of illicit capital are propelled by
three main types of drivers—macroeconomic, structural, and governance-related.
In China’s case, large and growing current account surpluses lead to capital
outflows, some of which may well be licit capital flight (such as private
sector hot money outflows). High and rising inflation could also contribute to
illegal capital flight, assuming owners do not wish to see the real value of
their holdings decline over time.
“The widely held perception that
the yuan is undervalued because of the trade surpluses may feed into
expectations of exchange rate revaluation in the future which could lead to
speculative inflows and round-tripped capital,” the report continues.
“Structural factors for China include non-inclusive growth, as a result of
which there are a larger number of tax havens from China during 2005-2011 were
illicit while 47.6 percent were licit.’
Business & Investment Opportunities
YourVietnamExpert is a division of Saigon Business Corporation Pte Ltd, Incorporated in Singapore since 1994. As Your Business Companion, we propose a range of services in Strategy, Investment and Management, focusing Healthcare and Life Science with expertise in ASEAN. Since we are currently changing the platform of www.yourvietnamexpert.com, you may contact us at: sbc.pte@gmail.com, provisionally. Many thanks.
No comments:
Post a Comment