China - Myopic pursuit of growth harms health, environment

RECENTLY Shanghai's environmental watchdog ordered 14 of the 17 lead-acid battery plants in the city to stop production pending investigation of toxic discharges.

The move has been taken after some children living in Kangqiao area were found to have excessive levels of lead in their blood in early September.

This is just one case suggesting how an industrial source of pride (as a contributor to local GDP) becomes a curse when some of its environmental costs are considered.

In other words, local officials can continue to talk gleefully of growth as long as they can pretend not to see its ecological and health consequences.

And the costs are high. About 34 percent of children in China have blood-lead levels that exceed the WHO limit, mainly attributed to exhausts from cars, according to researchers at the Beijing University Health Science Center, after reviewing 10 years of data.

In the United States, where economic growth is almost flat, less than 1 percent of children have blood-lead levels above the WHO limit.

While growth is relative, ephemeral and hard to maintain year after year, the effects of lead exposure in children appear to be long-lasting and irreversible.

Tim Jackson's "Prosperity Without Growth: Economics for a Finite Planet" gives an unusually candid analysis of what GDP purports to measure, and what it fails to take in.

The book explains that gross domestic product (GDP) is a common measure of economic growth, but it fails to consider the ecological damage caused by that growth.

By prioritizing growth, capitalism has raised productivity to a level that can only be sustained by excessive consumption.

In order to perpetuate this production-consumption cycle, capitalism has developed a huge advertising sector specialized in celebrating consumption power as a source of pride, pleasure, or evidence of elegance and success.

Unconditional glorification of consumption deliberately ignores such inconvenient truths as the depletion of vital resources, pollution of the air and water, and changing climate.

Age of irresponsibility

As the production capacity of capitalism is too much for its own consumption, it needs to convert more people into consumers of its products.

Thus the gospel of prosperity (read: consumption) is diligently preached to all homo sapiens.

Jackson calls for a redefinition of prosperity with an emphasis on the sense of security that allows people to live happier, more meaningful lives. The benefits of prosperity should be societal, not individual.

Ironically, prosperity is trumpeted most in an era of relentless and brutal onslaught on nature, as evinced by shrinking rainforest, melting icecaps, and a stockpile of weapons of mass destruction capable of blowing up the earth many times.

Human history demonstrates that the planet is big enough to meet everyone's needs, but not everyone's greed.

Recognition of the limits of the planet necessarily entails the debunking of the cult of GDP, which is difficult.

"The idea of a no growing economy may be an anathema to an economist. But the idea of a continually growing economy is an anathema to an ecologist," Jackson observes.

Today politicians and economists are more comfortable with sustainable growth, or an ever-lasting, continually expanding economic paradise, rather than no-growth or negative growth.

Jackson believes the financial panic of 2008 had its root in a myopic commitment to growth. Subsequent regulatory intervention to stimulate growth helped bail out Wall Street, which dictates American policy.

In China, where the crisis was largely conjectural while clamour for bailouts was loud, the government pumped a multi-trillion-yuan stimulus into the economy, quickly declared victory in defusing the crisis, and set the stage for runaway inflation that is still robbing us every day.

Wan Lixin

Business & Investment Opportunities
YourVietnamExpert is a division of Saigon Business Corporation Pte Ltd, Incorporated in Singapore since 1994. As Your Business Companion, we propose a range of services in Consulting, Investment and Management, focusing three main economic sectors: International PR; Healthcare & Wellness;and Tourism & Hospitality. We also propose Higher Education, as a bridge between educational structures and industries, by supporting international programs. Sign up with twitter to get news updates with @SaigonBusinessC. Thanks.