A
study from the Finance Ministry shows that children from poor Singaporean
families stand a good chance of moving up in life.
But this may not apply to younger generations
born later than the study's sample group of Singaporeans born between 1969 and
1978, says the study released yesterday.
Its findings show that the son of a father in
the bottom 20 per cent of income earners has at least a two-thirds chance of
breaking out of this low-income group.
And he has a 10 per cent chance of rising all
the way up into the top 20 per cent of income earners in Singapore.
The study also found that the level of
mobility in Singapore is better than that of the United States and United
Kingdom, similar to that of Germany, but worse than that of Canada and some
Nordic countries.
However, it cautions that these are general
and indicative comparisons as the data varies among countries.
The study also notes its findings show a
relatively higher income mobility than that of two recent studies: a 2007 paper
by assistant professor Irene Ng of the National University of Singapore (NUS),
and a 2009 one by Dr Ng, Ms Shen Xiaoyi of NUS and Dr Ho Kong Weng of Nanyang
Technological University.
Both papers used data from a national survey
of youths aged 15 to 29. But that data had various constraints, said the study
from the ministry.
Their sample size was small: 271 parent-child
pairs. And they measured incomes of youths aged below 30, which is
"generally regarded as too early to draw conclusions on life-time
mobility".
In addition, parents' incomes were not
directly measured. The papers were based on what the youths thought their
parents earned, added the ministry study.
By contrast, the new study draws on data from
the Department of Statistics, allowing it a much larger sample size of 39,500
father-son pairs. Considering sons, rather than children of both sexes, is
standard practice in such studies.
It measured the incomes of sons aged 30 to 39
in 2008, as well as the actual incomes of their fathers.
Using this more robust data, it found an
inter-generational correlation coefficient of 0.22 to 0.3, a statistical
measure of how much a father's income affects his son's economic chances.
The lower the number, the less effect a
father's income has on his son's - meaning that mobility is higher.
A coefficient of 0.3 implies a set of
probabilities and these include:
- The son of a father from the bottom fifth
has a one-third chance of staying there.
In other words, he has a two-thirds chance of
rising out of the bottom fifth.
- The son has a 44 per cent chance of making
it into the top three-fifths; a 25 per cent chance of reaching the top
two-fifths; and a 10 per cent chance of rising into the top fifth.
The converse is true.
A son whose father is in the top fifth has a
one-third chance of staying in the high-income group.
And a son whose father is in the middle fifth
has a roughly equal chance of moving up or down.
Despite these overall findings of
"moderate to high" mobility, the study found that mobility was lower
for the poorest.
Fathers' incomes had a slightly greater effect
on sons' incomes at the bottom 10per cent.
The correlation coefficient for this group is
between 0.27 and 0.36, compared to the overall coefficient of between 0.22 and
0.3.
It led the study to conclude that "there
is some evidence, though not strong, of lower mobility among the poor".
A greater concern perhaps is in the study's
cautionary note that "the relatively high mobility found in this paper may
not be generalised to other cohorts, in particular younger cohorts".
National University of Singapore sociologist
Paulin Straughan told The Straits Times that mobility for Singaporeans born in
the 1970s was especially high for two reasons.
First, progress began from a low base as among
the older generation, "very few had the privilege of formal
education".
Second, as the study itself notes, those born
in the 1970s would have "grown up at a time when Singapore's
transformation was very rapid".
There were many opportunities in education and
work then. But young Singaporeans today face a "very competitive"
world, said Dr Straughan.
As Singapore develops, there is now "a
certain level of saturation" at the top, she added. Well-to-do parents
want the best for their children and this hampers mobility as their children
have an edge.
"We have to recognise that not all
children will be starting off at the same point," said Dr Straughan.
Janice Heng
The Straits Times
Business & Investment Opportunities
YourVietnamExpert is a division of Saigon Business Corporation Pte Ltd, Incorporated in Singapore since 1994. As Your Business Companion, we propose a range of services in Consulting, Investment and Management, focusing three main economic sectors: International PR; Healthcare & Wellness;and Tourism & Hospitality. We also propose Higher Education, as a bridge between educational structures and industries, by supporting international programs. Sign up with twitter to get news updates with @SaigonBusinessC. Thanks.
No comments:
Post a Comment